The Bully’s Dare: A Why Choose Enemies-to-Lovers Romance (The Truth or Dare Series Book 1)
The Bully’s Dare: Part 1 – Chapter: 4

Live piano music plays. Candlelight flickers over white table cloth.

Pearl has dressed me in white. Which is not a good look for me. I look like a cream puff, the dress bunching awkwardly over my tummy. I crush my crème brulee with my fork.

The Blue Heron is the high-end restaurant that overlooks the marina. It has two entrances, one for the “common folk” of Long Island, and a second entrance exclusively for the boat-owners. The restaurant overlooks the marina, and you can see boats swaying in their slips through the siding. The Blue Heron calls itself the best place to catch the sunset on all of Hannsett Island, and they’re not wrong.

It’s incredibly romantic. And incredibly awkward when you’re sitting across from your mother and her new catch, who are both caught under the spell of the ambiance.

What is it about candlelight that makes people so disgustingly gooey?

“God, that sunset is beautiful,” Pearl muses, touching her manicured nails to her lips.

Four peels her blonde hair from her shoulder and places a kiss on the bare skin there. “The second most beautiful thing here,” he muses.

She laughs, a high bell-like sound which is definitely not genuine. I make a vomiting noise.

“Kenzi,” Pearl says my name as a warning, her eyes slits.

I pout. I crack another layer of toasted caramel.

Out of the corner of my eye, I see him. Jason King. He’s here with his family, and the temperature practically changes when they enter the restaurant.

They’re royalty. Jason’s father is a salt-and-pepper high-baller—perfectly groomed, wearing a blazer and a watch they could probably see from space. Mrs. King is ageless, tanned, and a Hollywood classic beauty. She’s fiddling with the shirt collar of what must be Jason’s older brother—they have the same strong jaw, same bright eyes, and the same prowling presence of a cougar.

Jason looks different without his beach board shorts and his posse. His shirt is buttoned up all the way to his Adam’s apple and the collar looks tight. He’s holding his wrist, hands falling about to his groin—classic defensive posture. He’s the tallest one in his family, a full head taller than his father, but next to the other man, he’s shrunken, somehow. His shoulders are hunched, head half-bowed like a chastised dog.

Jason might be the king of high schoolers, but in his father’s shadow, he’s a meager prince. And it shows.

Mr. King smiles passed the concierge and the owner of The Blue Heron greets him personally with a stiff handshake. I replace my eyes following them—the King family has become my new favorite nature documentary. And here, we see the Kings in the wild, prowling over their domain…

Blue sapphire eyes meet mine. Oh shit. I’ve been caught staring. I look away just when Jason’s penetrating graze connects with mine. Where to put my eyes? Outside. On the pearly stars. I twist my hair in my fingers.

Out of the corner of my vision, a too-tall figure approaches. “Shit,” I whisper under my breath.

“Mr. Blake. Misses Stratton.” Jason stands at the edge of our table, polite as a fucking church mouse.

“Jason,” Four smiles. He rests his hand on the back of Pearl’s neck. “How’s it going, son? Is your family here?”

“Yes, sir.” Jason’s eyes fix on me again. “I’m sorry to interrupt your dinner. Can I have a word with Kenzi?”

I roll my eyes and pick a bread stick off the table. I chew it the way Bugs Bunny might nibble his carrot in front of Elmer—you’re not the boss of me. “Whatever you have to say, you can say in front of the table,” I tell him.

“Okay.” His eyes are sparkling. There’s that mischief again. He comes out with it: “You’re the one who cast off my boat.”

He doesn’t look pissed. If anything, he looks…amused? There’s that smug smirk climbing his lips.

I shrug. “Maybe. Maybe not.”

“Wanna come to a bonfire tonight?”

“Oh, a bonfire, honey, that sounds like fun!” Pearl says too-enthusiastically.

“Pearl,” I chastise her. She’s completely ruining my cool.

Pearl sighs loudly. “Excuse me for wanting you to have some teenage escapades while you’re still young.”

Jason eyes me. “I’ll drive.”

I pretend to consider it. “Can I bring my friend?”

“Who’s your friend?”

“Donovan.”

A sliver of something cruel slides across Jason’s blue eyes. “I don’t think he’d like the crowd.”

“By that, you mean you don’t think the crowd would like him?”

His mouth sets. “Whichever.”

I shrug. “Then it doesn’t sound like my crowd, either.”

I scoop a forkful of crème brulee while Jason considers. “Okay,” he says finally. “He can come.”

“Cool. You can pick me up later.”

Jason’s smile returns. Calm. Controlled. Cocky. “See you then.” Then he nods towards Four and Pearl. “Enjoy the rest of your dinner.”

With that, he turns and leaves to join his own family again. They have, obviously, the best table in the house, with a perfect view of the boats swaying in the marina.

Pearl puts her lips to her wine glass. “He’s cute,” she says into her pinot noir and wiggles her eyebrows.

“If you’re into…that.” I shrug and try not to blush.

“What did he mean about his boat?” Four asks, his brow furrowed.

“Hey!” I jump in with a quick change of topic: “I was thinking—can you teach me how to fish tomorrow?”