Trick Shot: A Spicy Christmas Novella (Brother Puckers Book 1)
Trick Shot: Chapter 15

I take the lead, helping Riley move up the bed so she’s propped on the pillows. She looks fucking sexy, her voluptuous body a pretty contrast against my rumpled blue comforter and white pillows. Before she can breathe, Jace gets to work between her legs closing his mouth over the hard nub between her folds.

She cries out, her clit sensitive from the first two orgasms I gave her. But for what she’s about to experience, we want her to be as wet as possible. While Jace eats her out, finally tasting her sweetness from the source, I move behind him so I can have a little fun before the party officially starts. I get to my knees and spread his ass cheeks wide, revealing the rosebud I want to tease. It pulses a bit in anticipation, then I dive in. I use my tongue to rim him, dipping in and out as he curses into Riley’s pussy. He loves when I eat his ass, and the noises he makes are always out of this world.

He pushes his ass back, allowing me to pull his cheeks wider so I can get better access. From this point of view, I can see Riley gripping Jace’s tousled hair, crushing his willing mouth into her cunt as he tries to suffocate me with his ass. The sinful sight has my cock so painfully hard that it reminds me of the ornament I worked up Riley’s wet hole earlier. The need to be inside my pretty Shortcake while Jace has his way with her is almost unbearable. My skin is hot and itchy, and I thrust my hips against the bed to get some sort of relief. After another few dips of my tongue and a smack on his ass, I decide I can’t contain myself any longer. I crawl so I’m next to Riley, the heat of her pleasured body searing my skin.

“Get over here, Riley. I want your perfect cunt all over my dick.”

She flashes those stunning pine eyes at me, a slow smile inching on her lips as she removes her hands from Jace’s head. Jace doesn’t bother wiping the shine from his face as he wordlessly helps her straddle my narrow hips that I’ve propped up with a pillow. When the outer lips of her slick pussy connect with the hard length of me, I let out an almost painful hiss, my eyes rolling back. My aching desire to be inside her only intensifies as she presses her hands to my chest so she can move her needy slit over me in a steady cadence.

I grip my hands on the bold flesh of her waist. “Goddamn, Shortcake. Your pussy is burning me alive and I’m not even inside you yet.”

She whimpers. “I need to feel you fuck me. Please, I can’t wait anymore.”

“Get her on my cock, Jace.”

He doesn’t need to be told twice. Riley lifts her ass up a bit so Jace can free my leaking cock, his large hand wrapping around my Riley-soaked shaft as he pumps me a few times.

I glare at him, my tone scolding. “Don’t tease me, J.”

He fucking winks at me and gives my hard flesh one more tug for good measure before placing me at Riley’s entrance.

“Sink down, beautiful,” he coaches her.

“But the plug…”

He gives her a reassuring smile. “You’ll be fine, I promise. Your body is ready for us.”

After a moment, she exhales shakily and nods, using her hands on my chest to leverage her body as she torturously begins to lower herself on my length.

“Oh shit, oh shit,” she cries, her eyes squeezing shut. “Oh god, baby.”

Baby. I like the way she says it. The tone is delicate compared to how Jace says it, but it has my poor cock threatening to spill just the same. Fuck. I’m screwed. With everything I have, I pull my focus back to the goddess on top of me and force myself to not lose it.

“Just breathe, Riley,” I soothe. “You’re opening up so nicely for me.”

She whimpers again and Jace takes it as a cue to step in. He moves one of his hands to grasp her head while keeping his other on the base of my cock. He crushes his lips to hers, practically sucking the air from her lungs as a distraction. With his magical lips attached to hers, she lowers herself down inch-by-inch, her nails digging harder into my pecs the further she goes. It feels like heaven.

Jace removes his hand as she fully seats herself on me, the dimpled skin of her ass pressing down onto my pelvis. I let out a grunt of pleasure as Riley breaks the kiss and moans so loudly that my dick has its own heartbeat now.

“Oh fuck!” we chant together, her body falling forward so her round breasts mold to my chest and her damp forehead presses against mine.

“Such a good girl,” I murmur, brushing a lock of hair from her cheek. “You feel like a vice around my cock, Shortcake.” She sighs in response. “Let me know when you’re ready to move, okay?”

She nods, shifting her hips in small movements until noises that should be illegal spill from her pouty lips. I manage to pry my gaze from her to stare at Jace’s hulking nude form, one that I’ve come to know like the back of my hand. He’s still kneeling, his eyes on the space where Riley and I are joined while one hand fists that gorgeous cock of his and the other rests near her waist. The squeeze of Riley’s tight cunt while he jacks himself off is almost too much for my brain to handle.

Riley’s sex-laden voice thankfully pulls me back to reality. “I’m ready,” she says.

I grip her hips to lift her up a bit, one of my hands resting over the one Jace has on her.

“Hold on tight, Shortcake.”

Her eyes widen slightly just as I thrust my hips in a short upward motion. The gentle force causes her sharp nipples to rub against my chest in a way that makes my body quake.

“You feel,” Riley trails off, her lips brushing against mine, “so good.”

Her encouragement makes me punch my hips up harder, both of us crying out at the insane sensation of being joined together with no barriers.

“Your greedy pussy is gripping me so good, Shortcake. Fuck, you’re perfect.”

She tightens her already snug channel in answer, a fresh wave of her arousal leaking onto my balls. The bed rocks as she picks up speed, pressing herself up so that she can get a better angle to work herself on my cock at a slow pace. Jace’s breathing quickens as he strokes himself faster, and a bead of his pre-cum falls on to the comforter. A groan escapes my lips when Riley fucks herself harder on my cock. When I replace Jace’s blown-out hazel gaze, my chest tightens like a sling shot. His eyes are locked on mine, and within their depths I swear I see a million words unsaid.

It must be the intimacy of the moment, or maybe Riley is a magical unicorn sent to me on Christmas Eve to pull feelings from me that I’ve long buried—but I’m suddenly overwhelmed with my love for Jace. I think of the moment we met, how he picked me up and dusted me off. How he’s held my hand through hard times and had my back when I needed it.

I think of all the nights we’ve shared and the hours we’ve talked, and it all feels like too much. Too big. Too…everything. He shoots me a warm smile, one that says he knows what I’m feeling, and I swear my heart grows three sizes. I run my tongue along the back of my teeth and try to form words that would be appropriate, but there aren’t any.

Tension builds in my chest, so I squeeze my lids shut, willing the emotions inside me to calm. I’m trying too hard to understand why meeting this beautiful woman is what finally made me see that Jace and I should be more than what we are—or if I’m being honest with myself—admit that we already have been more. A lot more.

The bed moves, and the heat of Jace’s body sears into me. I don’t open my eyes as he tickles my jaw with his nose, his hot breath skittering across my face as he rains kisses all over my face and neck.

“We’ll talk later,” he whispers. Then he kisses me hard while Riley’s moan has me pulling my attention back to the moment. She deserves for me to be all here with her and Jace. And I’m committed to fulfilling all the promises I made her.

“I love watching you two together,” Riley says, her cunt squeezing the life out of me. “You’re both so handsome, so gentle yet rough and—” I thrust up inside her. “Fuck!” she cries.

“I love watching you ride my cock,” I say with a grunt, my tone playful and teasing. “Doesn’t she make a perfect slutty cowgirl, J?”

His hungry gaze roves over her body, both of us watching as she throws her head back and bounces on my cock. It’s one hell of a sight. Her large breasts swinging, her face riddled with pleasure as she takes what she wants. It’s amazing how far she’s come since we met in the airport only hours ago. It makes me even harder inside her. She’s so fucking good. When one of her hands leaves my chest so she can rub her clit, I know it’s time.

“She’s ready for you,” I tell Jace.

Riley halts her movements, eyes popping open to look at Jace’s straining cock.

“Do you really think it will fit?” she asks. Her voice is so goddamn cute I almost lose it again.

“Oh, Shortcake,” I say. “If I can take it, so can you.”

That needy whine escapes her lips again, and I know she really is ready for it. She’s capable of more than she gives herself credit for. I hope that when she leaves here, she feels more confident in herself and what she can do, and how amazing she is.

Jace kneels on the bed so he can kiss her forehead, whispering words of encouragement in her ear before he grabs the bottle of lube.

“Lie on my chest, Riley,” I instruct her.

She follows my orders, plastering her breasts to me as I embrace her and move my legs and hips a bit so we’re connected in every way possible. Jace positions himself behind her and palms her ass cheeks, running one of his thick fingers down her crack until he reaches the plug. He taps it playfully, and Riley hisses like a cat. It’s adorable and sweet that she thinks that will stop him from playing.

“Is your ass ready for my cock, beautiful girl?” He groans, running the broad head of himself up and down her crack.

“Yes, Daddy.”

Jace lets out a string of fucks and Riley grins at me. She has Jace figured out already. If he’s going to play, she’ll play, too.

He smacks her ass, and she moans against my neck.

“Harder, J. She likes it harder.”

Riley bites my pec, then cries out as Jace lays down a series of smacks that make her ass jiggle and her pussy clench around my dick so hard that my soul leaves my body.

“Jesus, you’re so fucking tight,” I say before grabbing her jaw to lay a sloppy kiss on her. She bites my lower lip as Jace spanks her a few more times. When she breaks away, panting, he stops.

“I’m going to pull the plug out now, Riley,” he says. “Relax and breath out when I do, okay?”

She nods, pressing her forehead into the crook of my shoulder. Jace catches my eye as he moves the plug around in her tight hole before slowly pulling it out. Riley cries out, her nails digging into my biceps. I’m sure that was sensitive as fuck, which makes the pounding we’re about to give her ten times more likely to have her passing out with pleasure.

I brush some hair from her forehead as Jace squirts a generous amount of lube on his fingers. I bring one of my hands to tilt Riley’s face so her pine green eyes are looking into mine.

“It’s gonna feel like a lot at first, but don’t push him out. Just relax and give into it. I promise you’ll be more than okay.”

Her face looks a bit nervous, but I can see the excitement shining behind it.

“I’m ready,” she says, breathing out.

I glance to Jace who looks as if he’s about to combust. He nods and puts the tip of his thick cock at her back entrance. This entire moment reminds me of the first time I bottomed for him. It was a little frightening to be honest, but so euphoric once I let myself take it. Now with Riley, it’s like I’m reliving that moment, but it’s ten times better because I’m inside her cunt and emotions are involved.

“Take a deep breath in, Riley,” Jace tells her gently. As soon as she does, he pushes the tip inside and she squeals.

“You’re okay, you’re okay,” I chant. “You’re such a good girl taking his big cock.” My words have her moaning, and I pet her hair while making sure to keep still.

She takes another breath, then says, “More, Jace.”

He guides himself in an inch more, his body trembling as he holds himself back. “You’re so snug, fuck Riley. I’m gonna come in this ass so hard.” He grunts, his voice more caveman than ever.

Riley’s pussy squeezes me again, and her fresh arousal wets us both. She fucking loves this. I’m already dreaming of all the ways we can fuck her, and we haven’t even finished one complete round yet.

“Jace, oh shit!” she cries as he moves further and further in.

“He’s halfway in.” I groan. “I can feel his cock inside you.”

“Halfway?!” she exclaims.

Jace manages a smile as he keeps himself from bottoming out like I know he wants to.

“You take our cocks like they’re meant for you, Riley,” Jace says, exhaling in pleasure.

I bite the inside of my cheek to try and hold myself together. I’ve DP’d women many times before this, but the chemistry between the three of us, it sets something off in me, as though I’m a born-again virgin. The sensation of Jace’s cock sliding in and in and in—it’s an experience I don’t think I can even describe.

“I’m so full, I’m—oh God, this is—oh shit!” Riley cries, her voice high-pitched.

I brush the hair from her face and make sure she’s breathing. Her eyes are glassy, and for a second I’m worried we’re hurting her.

“Are you good, Riley?”

She vigorously shakes her head in a nod. “I’m good, just—” Jace bottoms out and she screams. “Oh fuck, Jace!”

Jace hums in satisfaction and rubs the globes of her ass in appraisal. “You feel so fucking good, Riley. Jesus, you’re so perfect.”

“You are perfect,” I reiterate, kissing her lips as if I’m sipping a fine wine. When I’ve had my fill, her body relaxes against my chest and she tips her chin down.

“I think I need you both to move now,” she says.

Jace and I make eye contact. I signal him to make the first movement. We’ve been together for so long that our timing is practiced and efficient. If there’s something we’d always win first prize at, it’s group sex and satisfying our partners. And maybe making our clients millionaires, too.

As he pulls his cock out, then pushes back in, Riley and I let a string of expletives together. The feeling of us all connected, bare and silken, it’s…Like I said, I can’t describe it. The only thing I can think to say is it’s a fucking revelation.

“Lucas,” she moans out. “I need, I need…”

I scrunch my forehead together in pain from the name she just called me, but pretend she said Leo instead. “What do you need, Riley?”

“Move, touch me. Oh, fuck, I need something. More, anything!” she wails in heated desperation.

“Your wish is our command.” Jace moves out and I move forward, fucking her deep until she screams in pleasure. She bites my chest as I retreat and Jace thrusts back in from behind. We start a slow pace of seesawing back and forth to warm her up before we abandon playing nice. After a moment, I thread my fingers through her hair and force her eyes to mine.

“Can you get on your forearms for me?” I ask. “I want to suck your pretty tits while we fuck you.”

She bites her lip and nods her head. When she’s in position, I use my hands to grab my desired toys and squeeze them while Jace thrusts back in.

“Yes! Oh, Jace, Lucas, fuck!” she cries. Her face reflects pure ecstasy just as I latch my mouth onto one nipple and suck. Our girl writhes between us as Jace and I start to thrust at the same pace. Fuck. Our cocks seem to almost meld together as we fill her to the brim again and again.

“So good, beautiful. You’re such a little slut for our cocks, aren’t you?” Jace groans.

“Yes! Yes, you both feel so good inside me,” she keens.

I suck her nipple harder and she starts to move her hips with us. Like I said before, a natural.

Jace and I moan with her now, the sounds of her wet pussy and the slapping of skin the soundtrack to our Christmas debauchery.

“I’ve never felt this way before,” Riley murmurs, rocking her hips just right so she’s hitting her clit against me.

Jace thrusts harder. “Like what, beautiful?”

She expels another loud cry and says, “Like I’m falling and I don’t know when or where I’ll land.”

Jace moves one of his hands and grips a fistful of her hair, pulling back just enough that her back dips and her ass arches into Jace’s pelvis. The new angle gives me more room to thrust, and allows Jace more momentum as well.

Riley swears as we drill into her, the new sensation of Jace pulling on her scalp releasing more endorphins into her system. The image of her tits above me and her face strained in pleasure while Jace fucks the life out of her will forever be burned into my memory. Her pussy pulses around my cock, and I know she’s close.

“You can fall anytime you want, Shortcake. I promise we’ll catch you,” I say with conviction.

The green eyes I’ve come to adore flash open to meet mine, and I think I see tears form in them, but she quickly blinks them away before I can know for sure.

“Come for us, Riley,” Jace encourages her now.

His eyes meet mine, and by the tense lines between his brow, I know he’s ready to blow his load inside her. Imagining it dripping out of her luscious ass for the rest of the night has me right on the edge, ready to fall.

Riley undulates her hips, and I motion for Jace to bring her forward again. I want her sandwiched between us with his lips on mine while we come together. Jace lets go of her hair and I help ease her down on my chest. Riley trembles in my arms, as if she’s about to lose control.

“Spooning,” Jace tells me suddenly, pulling his dick out quick enough that she whines from the loss of it.

“We’re adjusting, beautiful.” He chuckles. “You’ll have my cock back in your ass in two seconds.” I can’t help but laugh, too. Only Jace could make this moment light and fun, while really I feel as if what’s happening here is changing everything.

Jace helps adjust us so that Riley and I are on our sides, her ass facing Jace as he spoons her from the right. The moment he’s in position he doesn’t give her any warning before thrusting his cock back in her willing hole.

“Jace!” Her hips shoot forward so fast that my cock goes deep inside her pussy to the point she screams again.

He sucks on her neck and huffs out a laugh. “You wanted it, beautiful.”

She leans her head back against his chest and opens her mouth so that he can slip his tongue inside. I watch them kiss as Jace reaches his arm across Riley until his hand replaces mine. We entwine our fingers, sandwiching her between us.

She breaks her lips away. “Harder, God please. Harder.”

I smirk at Jace, and we give our little slut what she asks. Our hips move in tandem, our bodies lost in a tangle of limbs and sweat. I don’t know what switch flipped—maybe it was the position—but it’s like we’ve become possessed with the need to feel and lose ourselves in each other.

The sound of skin on skin and our moaning fills my ears and my lower belly tenses. Riley’s pussy is fluttering, and I know she’s close. I free my hand from Jace’s and pull her leg over my hip so I can have better access to her clit.

At the touch of my fingers on her wet slit, she purrs with pleasure, her head dropping back against Jace’s shoulder as he fucks her harder. Every punch of his hips, he pushes her into me and it feels like heaven and sin all at the same time.

“Oh shit! I’m coming,” Riley says, practically weeping.

Jace bites into her shoulder gently as we both thrust harder. The friction of Jace’s cock and the sound of Riley’s oncoming orgasm has me almost there. I move my leg so that I trap Jace’s ankle and prop myself up just enough that he can meet me for a brief kiss. The closeness presses us all together, tightening Riley’s holes on our cocks enough for us to all make an unholy noise. I rub her sensitive bud once, then twice, and on the third time, she comes undone in our arms.

“Oh yes, oh God, oh god, yes, yes!”

“That’s it, baby. Squeeze our fucking cocks,” Jace smoothly commands, his dick still slamming home as he chases his own release.

Riley’s fingers grip his beard as she floats into outer space and her inner muscles shake and twitch. I continue to thrum her clit to draw out her orgasm as I piston my hips again and again.

“Fuck, Shortcake. This pussy, this ass, your body, it’s fucking ours,” I say.

Jace growls his approval as he reaches over to grab my thigh. He digs his short nails into my skin and we lock eyes. As we both pick up our pace, Riley cries out again as another orgasm builds inside her.

“Our little slut is needy for us, baby,” Jace says to me.

“Come again, Riley,” I demand.

She mewls and shakes her head. “I don’t think I can.”

“You can, and you will.” I rub her clit faster this time and roll my hips, her come coating my fingers as I work her higher and higher.

“Oh for the love of—” she cries.

Jace trails his hand from her breast down between our bodies. Before I see what he’s doing, his hand brushes against my cock as it moves in and out of her.

“Fuck, Jace!”

“I’m about to come,” he says with a groan. “Both of you, come with me.”

He squeezes my balls just as I pinch Riley’s clit, and it’s all over for us.

I can faintly hear Jace slamming into Riley and the grunt that comes with his release. I think I hoarsely cry both of their names, but I’m too distracted by Riley squirting all over my hand and her pussy milking the come out of my cock.

I don’t know how long I empty into her, but my release shoots out in thick jets, coating her insides and leaking out of her pussy. Goddamn, I think I feel Jace’s release in her ass. I don’t know if that’s possible, but I can feel him pulsing and the heat of it on my sensitive shaft.

My head falls to Riley’s shoulder where I plant a kiss on her salty skin. Her eyes are closed and her breathing is heavy, matching mine and Jace’s. Jace looks just as sated and happy as she does, a look that, now that I think of it, I haven’t seen much off late. Fuck, he’s beautiful.

When his eyes meet mine, I mouth, “I love you.”

His lips turn up, and he mouths it back before blinking down at Riley. She’s either floating in orgasmland or is about to fall asleep. That tightness in my chest returns as he brushes a lock of sweat soaked hair from her forehead to press a kiss to it. Riley hums in satisfaction, and then he returns his gaze to mine.

He doesn’t have to say what he’s thinking, because I already know. He wants Riley just as much as I do. The sex we had only proves that something is going on between us, even if it’s ridiculous and unexplainable; especially since we just met her.

I reach over her body to grab his hand and stroke my thumb across his knuckles. He grips my fingers and relaxes against the pillow, his eyes drifting shut. For now, I’m not going to think about what eventually has to be said between us all, including the matter of my real name. For now, reality can go to hell. I’m fine right here with Jace and Riley.